A few months ago, I posted about Rom Houben, the Belgian man who attracted media attention for allegedly being misdiagnosed as being in a vegetative state. Using a method known as facilitated communication, Houben seemed to offer vivid descriptions of his years spent conscious without being able to communicate with anyone. His medical staff is now reporting that he may not have been communicating his own thoughts. Further tests showed that Houben was unable to identify simple objects that were shown to him while his facilitated communicator was in another room.
It’s probably discouraging news for his family. The story of someone maintaining his mind and sense of self despite a severe brain injury is something we’d all like to believe. That’s not to say that this man isn’t conscious, but “conscious” can mean a lot of things. Perhaps he has some awareness of his surroundings but doesn’t possess the ability to articulate anything. Or maybe he inhabits a mental state that we can’t begin to understand or imagine.


